A jurisdictional REDD+ programme never gets credits equal to its avoided emissions. Between the gross number and the issued number sit three deductions. In an ART TREES Monitoring Report they appear in sections 11, 12 and 14. This post follows one verified report through that sequence, so you can see how each deduction is argued and where it shows up.
The deduction chain
The final table in section 14 has one row per year. In the source it read as follows.
| Step | Value (t CO2e) |
|---|---|
| Emission reductions for the year | 10,808,175 |
| Buffer withholding (5 percent) | 540,409 |
| Leakage deduction | none |
| Uncertainty deduction | 1,534,838 |
| Final TREES emission reductions | 8,732,929 |
The report adds that the table is based on output from a Monte Carlo analysis run on annual reductions, and that full calculations sit in the annexed workbook. Read the table top to bottom: each line is taken off the one above.
- The buffer is a share set aside as insurance against reversals. - The leakage line is zero when the whole national forest is in the accounting area. - The uncertainty line is the largest deduction in this example, about three times the buffer.
For the general concepts, see our posts on buffer pool mechanics and on the uncertainty deduction. This post is about how the report documents them.
Section 11: the buffer and three mitigation factors
Section 11 is titled Reversals. It asks the participant to apply the buffer contribution assessment tool and to provide evidence for any mitigation factors claimed. It also asks whether a reversal occurred in the period. In the example the answer was no.
The programme claimed all three mitigating factors, which together gave a 20 percent reduction in the buffer withholding, leaving a total withholding of 5 percent. The factors, as the report states them:
- Factor 1 (minus 5 percent): legislation or executive decrees that are actively implemented and demonstrably support REDD+, issued by a relevant agency or led from the presidential or prime ministerial office. - Factor 2 (minus 10 percent): demonstrated inter-annual variability of less than 15 percent in annual forest emissions over the prior 10 years used in TREES reporting. - Factor 3 (minus 5 percent): demonstrated national reversal mitigation actions, plan or strategy, aligned with Cancun Safeguard F.
Each factor needs its own evidence. For factor 1 the example cited a long-running national low-carbon strategy led by the head of state, a forest policy and plan, and forest regulations. For factor 3 it pointed to national commitments on sustainable forest management, timber legality and monitoring. These are policy documents, so the evidence is a citation trail, not a measurement.
Factor 2 is the numeric one, and the example shows how a reviewer-facing argument is built. The programme reported that its variation about the five-year mean was 16 percent, just over the 15 percent line, and that the figure rises over a ten-year window. It argued that for a country with very low annual deforestation area, a 16 percent swing is less than 2,000 hectares, so it is not a sign of high reversal risk. It claimed the factor on that basis. Whether a verifier accepts such reasoning is a judgement call, and the report was verified, but the lesson is practical: if you sit near a threshold, argue it in writing and show the absolute numbers.
Section 12: leakage
Section 12 asks for the leakage deduction from the leakage assessment tool. The example included 100 percent of national forest area in its accounting area. The report states that, following TREES guidance, there is then no leakage and no deduction. The same sentence appears in the Registration Document, where the anticipated deduction is set. For a subnational programme this line would not be zero, so do not copy it.
Section 14 and the uncertainty deduction
Section 14 asks for the quantified claim and the final calculation workbook. Two details matter for readers who try to reproduce the numbers.
- A footnote to the emissions table in section 10 says a Monte Carlo simulation combined and propagated errors to produce annual reductions and uncertainty estimates, so the final calculation uses stochastic inputs. The emissions printed in the report are deterministic, shown for ease of reading. - Emission factors in the report carry a 90 percent confidence interval, which is the input to that propagation.
So the uncertainty deduction cannot be recomputed from the printed tables. You need the workbook.
Practical points
- Build the evidence for each mitigation factor before registration. The Registration Document asks for the anticipated buffer with the same evidence. - Keep the buffer reasoning identical between the Registration Document and each Monitoring Report, and explain any change in section 16. - State "no reversal" outright. A blank looks like an omission. - Treat the workbook as part of the filing. Reviewers will test the table against it.
TREEO can help structure the evidence for each factor and the workbook reconciliation before you file.
Turn uncertainty into a plan
Sampling design and growth assumptions decide how much measured carbon survives conservative deduction. TREEO Carbon Simulator models sequestration scenarios and biomass growth before the field season.



