Two carbon credits can represent completely different physical realities and still get quoted in the same market, at the same time, sometimes to the same buyer. One represents an emission that didn't happen. The other represents carbon that used to be in the atmosphere and now isn't. The market has started pricing that difference explicitly — and the gap is large enough that knowing which type of credit you're looking at matters more than almost any other detail in a carbon transaction.
The gap, as the market prices it in 2024
+381%
removal credits traded over reduction/avoidance credits (2024)
$15.5/t
average price, forestry & land-use removal credits
$5.3/t
average price, forestry & land-use avoidance credits
2024
first year nature-based removal issuances matched avoidance issuances
What Each Credit Actually Represents
Avoidance credits (sometimes called reduction credits) represent emissions that would have happened under a business-as-usual scenario, but didn't, because of the project. A forest that would have been cleared for agriculture, and wasn't, generates avoidance credits — the carbon that stayed locked in standing trees is carbon that never entered the atmosphere. REDD+ (Reducing Emissions from Deforestation and Forest Degradation) projects are the largest category here: they credit the difference between a modeled deforestation baseline and what actually happened.
Removal credits represent carbon that was already in the atmosphere and has now been physically drawn down and stored — typically in new biomass, soil, or engineered storage. Afforestation and reforestation (ARR) projects, agroforestry systems adding new tree cover, biochar, and soil-carbon projects all generate removal credits: the carbon wasn't just prevented from being released, it was actively pulled out of the air and locked into something measurable.
The distinction sounds academic until you look at what each type actually requires a verifier to test. An avoidance credit requires proving a counterfactual — what would have happened without the project, which is inherently a modeled scenario, not a directly observed fact. A removal credit requires proving an addition — new biomass or carbon stock that exists now and didn't before, which is a directly measurable physical quantity. That difference in evidentiary burden is a large part of why the market now prices the two so differently.
The Price Gap Is Real, Recent, and Growing
According to Ecosystem Marketplace's State of the Voluntary Carbon Market 2025 report, removal credits traded at a 381% premium over reduction/avoidance credits in 2024 — up sharply from a 245% premium in 2023. That's not a rounding difference; it's a market saying, increasingly loudly, that these are not interchangeable products.
The World Bank's State and Trends of Carbon Pricing 2025 report breaks the same distinction down by exchange-traded price within a single sector, forestry and land use: removal credits averaged roughly $15.5 per tonne in 2024, while avoidance credits in the same forestry-and-land-use category averaged roughly $5.3 per tonne — essentially the same 3x-plus gap, measured a different way, by a different publisher.
| Credit type | Average price (2024, F&L category) | What it represents |
|---|---|---|
| Removal (ARR, agroforestry, biochar) | ~$15.5/t | Carbon physically added to a measurable stock |
| Avoidance/reduction (REDD+) | ~$5.3/t | Emissions prevented relative to a modeled baseline |
There's a second signal pointing the same direction: 2024 was the first year on record where nature-based removal credit issuances matched avoidance-credit issuances in volume, according to Climate Focus's VCM 2024 Review. Supply is shifting toward the category the market is willing to pay more for — which is exactly what a functioning price signal is supposed to produce.
Why the Gap Keeps Widening, Not Narrowing
A few converging factors explain the trend rather than a single cause. Buyers increasingly want credits with a shorter, more direct causal chain between the project and the claimed climate outcome — a physically measured addition to carbon stock is simpler to defend publicly than a counterfactual deforestation estimate, especially after several high-profile controversies over REDD+ baseline methodologies in recent years. Corporate net-zero commitments increasingly distinguish between "reduction" and "removal" in their own accounting frameworks, creating direct demand for removals specifically, independent of price. And recent-vintage credits carry their own separate premium — Ecosystem Marketplace found vintages under five years old commanded a 217% premium over older vintages in 2024, up from 53% in 2023 — which compounds with the removal premium when a credit is both a removal type and a recent vintage.
None of this means avoidance credits are becoming worthless or unnecessary — REDD+ and similar avoidance mechanisms remain essential for protecting existing carbon stock, which is not a problem removal credits solve. It does mean the two credit types are functioning as increasingly distinct products in the eyes of buyers, with distinct pricing, distinct evidentiary standards, and distinct roles in a credible carbon strategy.
Frequently Asked Questions
An avoidance (or reduction) credit represents an emission that was prevented relative to a modeled baseline — for example, forest that would have been cleared but wasn't. A removal credit represents carbon that was already in the atmosphere and has been physically drawn down into new biomass, soil, or storage — for example, new tree growth on previously cleared land.
Know which credit you're actually buying
Whether a project is generating avoidance or removal credits changes what evidence a verifier tests and what a buyer should be willing to pay.


