A "$25-70 per tonne blue carbon premium" has circulated widely enough in carbon-market commentary that it reads as settled fact. It isn't. A systematic search across every major price-tracking publisher in the space — S&P Global Commodity Insights, BeZero Carbon, the Climate Impact X exchange, Ecosystem Marketplace, Sylvera, and Abatable — turns up no transaction, assessment, or report anywhere near $70 per tonne. The real number is both lower and, because it's actually traceable, more useful.
What's actually documented
$25.25-$29.30/t
S&P Global Commodity Insights blue-carbon assessment range (Dec 2024-Aug 2025)
$27.80/t
clearing price, Climate Impact X mangrove auction, Nov 2022 (250,000 t sold)
~4-4.8x
multiple over the all-credit VCM average price ($6.10-6.34/t)
$0
named sources found supporting a $70/t transaction or assessment
The Documented Prices
S&P Global Commodity Insights launched a dedicated blue carbon price assessment in March 2024, and it's the closest thing this market has to an authoritative benchmark: $25.25 per tonne in December 2024, rising to a record $29.30 per tonne in August 2025. Separately, the Climate Impact X exchange ran a public auction in November 2022 for the Delta Blue Carbon-1 project — a mangrove restoration effort in Pakistan, certified under VCS plus the Climate, Community and Biodiversity standard — which cleared at $27.80 per tonne for 250,000 tonnes, with 30% of bid volume coming in above $35 per tonne. BeZero Carbon's tracked range for blue carbon transactions runs $13-35 per tonne on average, with occasional outliers reaching $40. An earlier, smaller transaction worth noting for context: Colombia's Vida Manglar mangrove project sold its first-round credits around $15 per tonne back in 2021.
| Source | Price point | What it covers |
|---|---|---|
| S&P Global Commodity Insights | $25.25-$29.30/t | Assessment, Dec 2024-Aug 2025 |
| Climate Impact X auction | $27.80/t clearing | Delta Blue Carbon-1, Pakistan, Nov 2022, 250,000t |
| BeZero Carbon | $13-35/t (outliers to $40) | Tracked transaction range |
| Vida Manglar (Colombia) | ~$15/t | First-round sales, 2021 vintage |
Every one of these is a named source with a stated date. None of them is $70.
The Question Nobody Was Answering: Premium Relative to What?
The other problem with the old "$25-70 premium" framing is that it never specified a reference price — a premium is meaningless without stating what it's a premium over. Once that question gets answered properly, the actual multiple is genuinely striking. Against the all-credit voluntary carbon market average of roughly $6.10-6.34 per tonne (Sylvera and Ecosystem Marketplace, 2024-2025 data respectively), blue carbon's $25-29 range works out to a 4-4.8x multiple — a premium of roughly $19-23 per tonne over the market baseline. Measured against a narrower, more directly comparable reference — exchange-traded forestry and land-use removal credits, which averaged around $15.5 per tonne in 2024 per World Bank data — the blue carbon premium is smaller but still real, at roughly $10-14 per tonne.
That's the honest version of the story: blue carbon credits do command a real, substantial, multiply-documented premium over the broader market. It's just a 4x premium with a named source behind it, not an unsourced range that happened to include a much larger number.
Why the Premium Exists, and Why It's Still a Small Market
Blue carbon (predominantly mangrove-based) credits remain a genuinely thin market — roughly 0.2-0.35% of total voluntary carbon market issuance, an estimated 6-7 million tonnes issued to date, from something on the order of ten issuing projects, nearly all of them mangrove restoration or conservation. That scarcity is itself part of the pricing story: a market this small, with this few sellers, doesn't behave like a liquid commodity market, and prices can move meaningfully on a single large transaction or a single new project entering supply.
The premium itself likely reflects a mix of factors the data doesn't fully separate: blue carbon projects typically carry strong co-benefits (biodiversity, coastal protection, community livelihoods) that buyers increasingly pay for directly; mangrove carbon stocks are unusually concentrated in soil rather than biomass, which some buyers view as a more durable, harder-to-reverse form of storage; and the category benefits from the same broader shift toward removal-type and nature-based credits documented across the wider market. None of that adds up to a clean, single-variable explanation — but it's a considerably more defensible story than repeating an unsourced number.
Frequently Asked Questions
Named, dated sources put the price in the $13-35 per tonne range, with a documented assessment benchmark of $25.25-$29.30 per tonne from S&P Global Commodity Insights (December 2024 to August 2025) and a $27.80 per tonne auction clearing price from a 2022 mangrove project sale.
Where the real premium comes from
Blue carbon's price advantage is real and traceable — but it comes from documented scarcity and co-benefits, not a headline number nobody can source.

