Stakeholder engagement is the part of the Climate, Community & Biodiversity (CCB) Standards that project teams most often under-document. Criterion G3 in version 3.1 does not simply ask for "community consultation". It defines what full participation means, what information must be given, how consultation must be run and what record must remain. This article covers the information and consultation parts. Grievances and worker relations, also in G3, have their own articles.
Full and effective participation
The concept statement says communities and other stakeholders are involved through full and effective participation, covering access to information, consultation, participation in decision making and implementation, and free, prior and informed consent. A footnote defines the phrase: meaningful influence of all relevant rights holder and stakeholder groups who want to be involved throughout the process.
Timely and adequate information must be accessible in a language and manner that communities understand.
Access to information: three duties
### 1. Documentation access
The proponent describes how full project documentation has been made accessible to communities and other stakeholders. A footnote says full documentation includes the project description and the monitoring reports as they become available through the project lifetime.
It also describes how summary documentation, including how to reach the full documents, has been actively disseminated to communities in relevant local or regional languages, and how widely publicised information meetings have been held.
A further footnote sets minimums for the summary:
- before validation, it covers at least the information required by the first nine indicators of G1, - before verification, it covers at least monitoring results showing that the project has delivered net positive climate, community and biodiversity benefits.
### 2. Costs, risks and benefits
The proponent explains how relevant and adequate information about potential costs, risks and benefits has been given to communities, in a form they understand and in a timely manner, before any decision they are asked to make about participating. A footnote says these should be identified through a participatory and transparent process, and cover direct and indirect effects, including social, cultural, environmental and economic aspects, human rights and rights to land, territories and resources. Costs include responsibilities and opportunity costs.
### 3. The audit process itself
The proponent describes how it explained the validation or verification process to communities, gave timely notice of the auditor's site visit before it occurred, and facilitated direct and independent communication between communities, or their representatives, and the audit body.
Consultation: what "effective" means
The consultation indicator asks the proponent to describe how communities, including all community groups, and other stakeholders have influenced project design and implementation through effective consultation. The aim is to optimise benefits, respect local customs, values and institutions and maintain high conservation values.
A footnote spells out effective consultation. It requires the proponent to:
- inform and engage broadly, using socially and culturally appropriate methods, so people can meaningfully influence the subject, - be gender and inter-generationally sensitive, with special attention to vulnerable or marginalised people, - meet at mutually agreed locations, through representatives designated by the groups themselves according to their own procedures, - allow different approaches for different groups, - give potentially affected groups a chance to evaluate impacts, raise concerns, express desired outcomes and comment on project design including the theory of change, both before design is final and during implementation.
The same footnote adds three required elements of consultation:
1. participatory identification of ecosystem services important to communities and of high conservation values, for example through participatory mapping, 2. an evaluation of the type and magnitude of impacts from project activities, 3. a participatory design of the feedback and grievance procedure.
Record and feedback loop
Two rules shape the paper trail:
- Proponents must document consultations and indicate if and how the project design and implementation were revised based on the input. - A plan must be developed and implemented to continue communication and consultation between proponents and communities, to support adaptive management through the project life.
A footnote defines adaptive management as an approach that accepts that management must proceed without complete information, and treats management as a way of learning.
Consultations must be held directly with communities and stakeholders or through legitimate representatives, with adequate sharing of information to group members.
Projects already under way
A footnote deals with timing. If it is unclear whether a project will be implemented, preliminary consultations are acceptable provided full consultations are planned before the project starts. For a project already under implementation, the proponent must either provide documentation of appropriate consultation during the design phase, or show how more recent consultations were effective in evaluating community benefits and adapting design.
Participation in decisions and implementation
The proponent also describes the measures needed and taken to enable effective participation of all communities and community groups that want and need to be involved, in design, implementation, monitoring and evaluation over the project lifetime, in a culturally appropriate and gender sensitive manner.
An evidence list
This is our reading, not standard text:
- A dissemination log showing documents shared, languages used and dates. - Meeting records with attendance by group, location and how representatives were chosen. - Output from participatory mapping. - A change log connecting input received to changes made in the design. - The ongoing communication plan with a schedule. - Records of auditor visit notices.
Common gaps
- English-only documents in communities that speak another language. - Consultation after the design is already fixed. - Attendance sheets with no breakdown by group. - No link between feedback and any design change.
Takeaway
Under G3 the record is part of the requirement. Keep what was said, who said it and what changed as a result.
Track what happens after planting
Survival rate is the assumption that quietly decides a restoration forecast. TREEO Dashboard monitors planting cycles and tracks survival so the number you report is the number you measured.



