The Climate, Community & Biodiversity (CCB) Standards version 3.1 have three optional Gold Level criteria. GL2, Exceptional Community Benefits, is the one that matters most to smallholder schemes and community-led projects. It is a long criterion with a clear structure: an entry test, then a series of equity and governance requirements. This article walks through it.
What GL2 is about
The concept statement says the project is smallholder or community led and implemented on land they own or manage, and/or is explicitly pro-poor in terms of targeting benefits to globally poorer communities. It delivers equitable well-being benefits, short term and long term, and strengthens security and empowerment. Governance arrangements enable full and effective participation in decision making, implementation and management, and manage the risks of aggregating smallholders or community members at scale.
One sentence in the concept goes further than most. Benefits must be shared equitably not only with smallholders or community members as a group, but also among them, so that marginalised and vulnerable households and individuals also gain.
A footnote defines smallholders or community members as households within the communities that are actively participating in the project.
The entry test: two routes
The first indicator offers two alternatives. A project needs only one.
| Route | What must be shown |
|---|---|
| (a) Rights | Smallholders, community members or communities own or have management rights, statutory or customary, individually or collectively, to land in the project area, and have the right to claim that their activities will or did generate the project's benefits |
| (b) Context | The project zone is in a low human development country, or in an administrative area of a medium or high human development country where at least 50 percent of households within the communities are below the national poverty line |
Route (a) is about who controls the land. Route (b) is about poverty context. A project on community-managed land can use (a) wherever it is. A project on other land can use (b) if the poverty condition holds.
The seven requirements after entry
After the entry test, GL2 asks for the following.
### Net positive well-being, short and long term
Demonstrate that the project generates short-term and long-term net positive well-being benefits for smallholders or community members. Include well-being indicators in the monitoring plan. The assessment must include an evaluation by the affected people themselves. A footnote explains that short-term benefits include significant benefits that begin to flow in time to provide incentives that outweigh the costs and risks of taking part.
### Participation risks
Identify, through a participatory process, the risks to smallholders or community members of taking part. The examples named are trade-offs with food security, land loss, loss of yields and short-term and long-term climate change adaptation. Explain how the design avoids such trade-offs and the measures taken to manage the risks. Include risk indicators in the monitoring plan.
### Marginalised and vulnerable groups
Identify marginalised or vulnerable community groups. Demonstrate net positive well-being impacts for all of them. Show that barriers or risks that might prevent benefits reaching them have been identified and addressed. Show that measures exist to identify any marginalised or vulnerable members whose well-being may be harmed, and that harm is avoided or mitigated.
The footnote definitions are useful. Marginalised people have little or no influence over decision making, and marginalisation may relate to age, gender, ethnicity, socio-economic status and religion. Vulnerable people lack secure access to the assets that livelihoods rely on and face high exposure to external stresses including climate change. Forest dependency can be an important factor, and marginalisation often makes vulnerability worse.
### Women
Demonstrate net positive impacts on the well-being of women, and that women take part in or influence decision making. Include indicators of impacts on women in the monitoring plan.
### Benefit sharing mechanism
Describe the design and implementation of a benefit sharing mechanism. Show that smallholders or community members fully and effectively took part in defining both the decision-making process and the distribution mechanism. Show transparency, including on project funding and costs as well as on benefit distribution.
### Communication of benefits, costs and risks
Explain how relevant and adequate information about predicted and actual benefits, costs and risks has been communicated, and provide evidence that the information is understood. Evidence of understanding goes beyond showing that a meeting was held.
### Governance and capacity
Describe the project's governance and implementation structures, including any self-governance or aggregation structures, and demonstrate that they enable full and effective participation. Demonstrate how the project is developing the capacity of smallholders or community members and relevant local organisations to take part actively in design, implementation and management.
What the monitoring plan must carry
GL2 is repeatedly tied to the monitoring plan. Indicators are required for well-being, participation risks and women. So the community monitoring plan cannot be written without reading GL2 first if the project seeks this level.
A checklist
This is our reading, not standard text:
- Decide the entry route and gather the evidence for it, either rights documents or poverty data for the administrative area. - Run a participatory risk workshop and keep its output. - Keep a register of marginalised and vulnerable groups with the barriers found and the response to each. - Document how the benefit sharing mechanism was designed, with participants named by group. - Test understanding, for example by asking participants to explain the benefit rules back.
Common weaknesses
- Benefit sharing described between the project and the community but not within the community. - Women counted as participants without evidence of influence on decisions. - Entry route claimed with no data. - No risk indicators in monitoring.
Takeaway
GL2 rewards projects where the people on the land control the project and share its benefits fairly. The evidence is mostly participatory records, so it must be built while the project is being designed.
Track what happens after planting
Survival rate is the assumption that quietly decides a restoration forecast. TREEO Dashboard monitors planting cycles and tracks survival so the number you report is the number you measured.



