A waterfall falls over a rocky cliff surrounded by bright green forest and a blue sky with thin clouds, viewed from below.
← Back to blog

Grouped Projects Under CCB: Eligibility Criteria and Scalability Limits

Sustainability•9 November 2026•TREEO Indonesia•5 min read

Many land-based projects start small and add new plots, farms or communities over time. The Climate, Community & Biodiversity (CCB) Standards version 3.1 provide for this through "grouped projects". The rules sit in criterion G1, with a related point in G4. This article sets out what the standard asks of a grouped project and why the limits matter.

What a grouped project is

A footnote in the standard defines it. A grouped project allows additional project areas that meet pre-established eligibility criteria to be added after the original validation. Conformance with the CCB Standards is then assessed for the new activities at the next validation or verification of the project against the CCB rules.

Two things follow:

- The first validation does not freeze the project to a fixed list of parcels. - New areas are not waved through. They are tested later, against the criteria the project itself set at the start.

The project zone gets wider

The standard defines the project zone as the area that contains the project area and in which project activities directly affecting land and resources are implemented. For a grouped project it adds a clause: the project zone also includes all potential project areas, meaning all potential new land areas where project activities that aim to generate net climate benefits may be implemented after the initial validation.

This has a design consequence. The proponent must think about the possible future footprint at the beginning, because the zone, and the baseline studies for communities and biodiversity that depend on it, must cover it.

Three pieces of information a grouped project must provide

The G1 grouped project indicators say the following information shall be provided:

1. Areas and communities. Specify the project areas and communities that may be included, and identify any new project areas and communities included since the last CCB validation or verification. 2. Eligibility criteria and process. Specify the eligibility criteria and the process for expansion. Demonstrate that these have been met for any new project areas and communities added since the last audit. 3. Scalability limits. Establish scalability limits, if applicable, and describe the measures needed and taken to address risks to climate, community and biodiversity benefits if the project expands beyond those limits.

The word "shall" marks these as requirements, though the scalability limits come with the qualifier "if applicable".

The five conditions in the eligibility criteria

A footnote says the eligibility criteria must include conditions on new areas. In the standard's terms, new areas must:

- adopt the project activities specified in the project description and apply them in the same manner as specified there, - be subject to the same climate, community and biodiversity without-project scenarios as determined for the project, - have similar characteristics with respect to additionality, - be subject to the same stakeholder engagement processes described in G3 and the same respect for rights to lands, territories and resources, including free, prior and informed consent, described in G5, - have similar monitoring elements.

Put simply, a new area has to look like the original in activity, baseline, additionality, social process and monitoring. A new plot that needs a different baseline story, or where communities were not consulted in the same way, does not fit the criteria.

What scalability limits are

Another footnote defines the term. A scalability limit is the scale beyond which, if new project activities are added, the project may not generate net positive climate, community or biodiversity benefits. The standard gives examples:

- capacity limits, - economic and managerial constraints, - thresholds for expansion beyond which there may be negative impacts on communities and biodiversity.

This is a practical idea. A team of a given size can support a certain number of households. A local ecosystem can take a certain amount of change. The standard asks the proponent to say where that point is, if there is one, and what happens when growth goes past it.

The link with G4

In criterion G4, the management capacity criterion, grouped projects have their own line. The proponent must identify any new entities included in the project since the last validation or verification. So expansion is tracked not only by land and communities, but also by the organisations involved in delivery.

How it plays out over time

Based on the text, a grouped project cycle looks like this:

1. Validation sets the eligibility criteria, the process and any limits. 2. During implementation, new areas and communities are added using that process. 3. At the next validation or verification, the project lists what was added and shows that each addition met the criteria.

A practical checklist

This is our reading, not standard text:

- Write eligibility criteria that mirror the five conditions above, one line each. - Keep an expansion register with dates, locations, communities and the evidence for each criterion. - Keep consultation and consent records for each new community in the same form as for the first. - Decide early whether any scalability limit exists and write it down, with a response plan. - Update the list of entities when partners are added.

Common problems

- Eligibility criteria that are so loose that almost any land qualifies. - Adding areas with a different land use history but applying the original baseline unchanged. - Skipping the full consent process in newly added communities because the first group agreed. - No record of expansion decisions when the audit arrives.

Takeaway

A grouped project is flexible only if its rules are written clearly at the start. Define who may join, prove each addition against those rules, and say where growth would harm the benefits the label stands for.

Check the land before you commit

Eligibility turns on land history and forest cover at a cut-off date. TREEO Eligibility runs satellite-based forest cover detection on your area of interest — before a single seed goes into the ground.

Related Articles

CCB Grouped Projects: Eligibility and Scalability | TREEO Indonesia