Under the Clean Development Mechanism, there is no single world definition of forest for afforestation and reforestation projects. Each host country picks its own, inside limits. The country's designated national authority, the DNA, communicates the choice. That choice then decides which land is eligible. This article explains the ranges, the procedure and the consequences.
The permitted ranges
A non-Annex I Party selects one value for each parameter, under paragraph 8 of the annex to decision 5/CMP.1, within these ranges:
| Parameter | Permitted range |
|---|---|
| Minimum land area | 0.05 to 1 hectare |
| Minimum tree crown cover | 10 to 30 percent |
| Minimum tree height at maturity | 2 to 5 metres |
These ranges appear in version 11.0 of the CDM glossary, in force from 8 September 2022, and in the CDM Methodology Booklet. A thesis chapter attributes them to the Marrakesh Accords, and the UNFCCC decision text gives the same crown-cover and area ranges. Under the same rules, a minimum width is also part of the thresholds referenced for A/R eligibility.
One discrepancy is worth noting. A UN-REDD glossary excerpt gives a 0.1 hectare minimum area, which differs from the 0.05 to 1 hectare range in the CDM glossary. We do not resolve it here.
For comparison, the older global forest definition from FAO is more than 0.5 hectares, more than 10 percent cover and 5 metres. It sits at the low end of the cover range and inside the area range, but its values are not the same thing as a host country's single chosen numbers.
What the DNA does
- The selected values are reported to the CDM Executive Board by the DNA of the non-Annex I Party. - Values can be changed only if the Party is not host to a registered A/R project activity, or to one with a pending request for registration. - The change procedure was adopted at the 40th meeting of the Executive Board on 17 June 2008. - At its 39th meeting in May 2008 the Board considered requests from Ghana and India and agreed in principle to allow changes only where no registered A/R project exists in the country. - The UNFCCC page listing change submissions shows the Democratic Republic of the Congo (11 November 2008), India (7 July 2008) and Ghana (17 June 2008).
The Board report also states that the forest definitions a country established under decisions 11/CP.7 and 19/CP.9 apply.
An illustration of how far choices can differ: India's 2008 change request proposed 0.05 hectares, 15 percent cover and 2 metres, while a project design document for an Indian reforestation programme records 0.05 hectares, 30 percent and 5 metres. We do not say which was in force on any given date.
How the definition drives land eligibility
A/R eligibility is shown by demonstrating that the land sat below the national forest thresholds communicated by the DNA. The key tests are:
| Requirement | Reforestation | Afforestation |
|---|---|---|
| Time reference | Land was non-forest on 31 December 1989 | Woody vegetation below the host thresholds for at least 50 years |
| Basis | Host Party thresholds for cover, height, area and width | Same |
| Approval | Host Party approval is required at registration | Same |
Further points from the UNFCCC afforestation and reforestation brochure and Board guidance:
- The project must establish, or have the potential to establish, forest as defined by the host Party. - Young stands and plantations that are below the thresholds still count as forest if they can reach them. - Because definitions vary by country, the same land can count as deforested in one country and forested in another. - The brochure uses a 15 percent crown cover threshold only as an illustration for an unnamed host country.
A worked comparison
Take a stand at 20 percent crown cover. Under a host country choosing the 10 percent end of the range, it is forest, so it fails the eligibility test for reforestation. Under a country choosing 30 percent, it is below the threshold, so it can be eligible if the other tests are met. The land is identical. Only the national choice differs. This is illustrative arithmetic, not a statement about any particular country.
Brazil's institutional record as an example
The source records Brazil's DNA, an interministerial commission, in some detail: created by presidential decree on 7 July 1999, internal rules approved on 17 April 2000, communicated to the UNFCCC as Brazil's DNA on 19 September 2002, and resolutions in 2003, 2005 and 2006 on project approval procedures. No forest-definition values from that authority were found in the source, so we cite the timeline only to show how a DNA's role is formalised.
What this means in practice
- Look up the host country's communicated values, not a global default, before testing eligibility. - Document the 1989 and 50-year evidence with dated imagery or records, since eligibility is time-referenced. - Do not assume a threshold carries over from another country or another programme.
What we could not establish
- Per-country values for most host countries. A 2007 research paper tabulates values for 13 DNAs, but the values were not in our source. - Indonesia's own submission to the Executive Board, which we could not locate. Its 2004 national instrument falls inside all three ranges, but whether and when it was communicated is not confirmed.
Check the current UNFCCC listing for the host country before relying on any number.
Turn climate goals into a verified portfolio
TREEO connects the full carbon cycle — eligibility, simulation, real-time monitoring and registry-ready reporting — combining expert consulting with dMRV technology so the evidence exists before anyone asks for it.



