Portrait low-angle view up a huge buttressed tree whose pale flared base narrows into a trunk under a green leafy canopy.
← Back to blog

Two Kinds of Growth in Monitoring Data, and Only One Is Biological

Sustainability•19 November 2026•TREEO Indonesia•4 min read

When a monitoring export shows more trees measured this year than last, it is natural to say the project is growing. That is true of the campaign, not of the trees. Monitoring analyses work best when they keep two ideas of growth apart.

The two concepts

ConceptWhat changesWhat it means
Count growthThe number of measurements between two yearsExpansion of the measurement or planting campaign
Same-pair growthThe mean diameter of the same plot and species pairs measured in both yearsA proxy for biological growth

Count growth, per species, plot or region, mostly reflects new plots being registered and measured. It is coverage. Report it as such.

Same-pair growth is the biological proxy. It is built from pairs of a plot and a species that were measured in both year A and year B.

Building the same-pair table

The rules are simple and strict:

1. A pair enters the table only if it has at least one measurement in both years. 2. Growth for each pair is the mean diameter in year B minus the mean diameter in year A. 3. Roll up to species or region with a weighted mean, with each pair weighted by its number of trees in year B. 4. Require a species to appear in at least three plots before ranking it by growth. Otherwise single-plot noise decides the order.

Because the same plot and species is compared with itself, a change in who was measured cannot create a change in size.

The composition effect

A cross-sectional comparison of mean diameter per species between two years mixes biology with changing composition. If new young plantings enter the second year, the mean falls, even if every older tree grew. The reverse can also happen.

Only the same-pair table isolates biological change. If you must show the cross-sectional figure, label it as including composition effects.

Growth per month and per year

Some reports use a descriptive template with growth in centimetres per month, defined as mean diameter divided by mean age in months. Growth per year is that figure times twelve.

Points to note:

- Age in months here is the measurement year minus a base year, times twelve. It has whole-year resolution only, because the planting month is not known. - Where mean age is zero or missing, the growth value is null. Division by zero is impossible and no substitute is imputed. - Rows without a usable measurement year are left out of age and growth aggregates, but kept in counts, diameter and carbon statistics. - Each grouping gets an all-species row per group, with the species field blank, so totals are visible alongside species rows.

Note that this is a mean-over-age ratio, a different thing from same-pair growth. It assumes the diameter you see is the accumulated result of the age you computed. If the age field is wrong, the ratio is an artefact.

Caveats to put in every report

1. Composition effect. State that mean change per species in cross-section mixes biology with a changing measured population. 2. Unreliable base year. If a duplication check shows that one tree appears in several cohorts, age and growth columns are artefacts. Diameter and carbon per measurement event stay valid. 3. Unknown timestamps. Rows with no usable date cannot take part in a trend. Check their share before comparing year totals. 4. Unmatched points. GPS error or unregistered plots leave points outside any plot. They are kept so totals stay complete, and listed under a separate region label. 5. Negative or zero ages. These occur in real data and are kept and counted. 6. Test projects. Keep them for completeness, and say so. 7. Partial years. A year with only a handful of measurements can distort year-on-year comparison.

Region assignment

Regions come from the plot centroid, the mean of its ring vertices, and not from single GPS points. Measurements inherit their plot's region. Points outside every plot get an unmatched label. If region thresholds are rules of thumb tuned to one project, set them per project and say so, and note that the order of rules matters: the first matching rule wins.

A short checklist

- Report count growth as coverage. - Build same-pair growth for biology. - Weight by year-B trees and require three plots for ranking. - Label any cross-sectional mean change as affected by composition. - Run the cohort check before using age. - List the caveats that apply, with counts.

For how to present growth evidence to a verifier, see our article on presenting growth curves for verification, and for the modelling side, our overview of growth modelling tools for tropical forestry.

Turn uncertainty into a plan

Sampling design and growth assumptions decide how much measured carbon survives conservative deduction. TREEO Carbon Simulator models sequestration scenarios and biomass growth before the field season.

Related Articles