Documentary photograph illustrating deforestation in the Project Scenario
← Back to blog

Deforestation in the Project Scenario: The Number Nobody Wants to Report

Carbon Standards•12 October 2026•TREEO Indonesia•2 min read

Every REDD+ project loses some forest. Not because the intervention failed, but because no intervention stops all clearing, given that some pressure is beyond the project's control, and some leaks through despite it. The credited amount is the difference between the baseline and this number, which means understating it directly inflates the claim.

Why It Is Measured Differently From the Baseline

The baseline is modelled. The project scenario is observed. They are not symmetric activities, and that asymmetry creates a specific risk.

BaselineProject scenario
SourceHistorical or jurisdictional allocationDirect observation over the period
MethodAnalysis, set onceRepeated remote sensing plus ground checks
Bias direction if sloppyUpward (inflates avoided loss)Downward (also inflates avoided loss)

Both errors push the same way. A conservatively-set baseline paired with a rigorously-measured project scenario is credible; the reverse combination is the profile of every REDD+ project that has been publicly criticised.

What Counts as Deforestation Here

The definition must match the one used in the baseline analysis. Same minimum mapping unit, same canopy cover threshold, same forest definition.

This sounds obvious and is violated regularly, usually when the baseline came from a jurisdictional dataset at one resolution and the project monitors with higher resolution imagery at another. Higher resolution detects smaller clearings, so the project scenario captures events the baseline analysis would have missed. Comparing the two directly overstates project period loss, which is conservative, or the reverse if the mismatch runs the other way.

Either way, the fix is to harmonise the definitions before comparing, and to state in the monitoring report that it was done.

Small Clearings Are the Hard Part

Large clearings are easy to detect and hard to hide. The measurement difficulty is in smallholder scale clearing, specifically patches below the mapping unit that accumulate across a landscape into a substantial total.

A project that reports zero deforestation across a populated landscape is usually reporting the limits of its detection method rather than an absence of clearing. Assessors know this, and an implausibly clean result draws more scrutiny than a modest, well-documented loss.

Reporting It Well

The monitoring report should show the detected clearing, the detection method and its minimum detectable size, the ground verification performed on a sample of detections, and the accuracy assessment of the classification.

That last item matters most. A change map without an accuracy assessment is an unquantified claim, and standards increasingly require the assessment with stated confidence intervals rather than a single accuracy percentage.

Reporting real losses honestly is not a weakness in a project file. It is the thing that makes the avoided losses believable.

Turn climate goals into a verified portfolio

TREEO connects the full carbon cycle, encompassing eligibility, simulation, real time monitoring, and registry ready reporting, thereby combining expert consulting with dMRV technology so the evidence exists before anyone asks for it.

Related Articles

Estimating Deforestation in the REDD+ Project Scenario | TREEO Indonesia