Documentary photograph illustrating inside the Ex-Ante Library
← Back to blog

Ex-Ante Carbon Estimation: Projecting Tonnes Before Anything Is Planted

Technology & Innovation•29 October 2026•TREEO Indonesia•3 min read

The first question anyone asks about a restoration project is how many tonnes it will produce. It has to be answered before the land is secured, before financing, and long before a single tree exists to measure. That estimate drives every subsequent decision, and it is routinely produced in a spreadsheet nobody can reproduce.

What the Tool Takes In

InputWhy it matters
Species with allometric formulasDifferent species, different growth trajectories
Plot-level seedling distributionSpacing and mix determine the stand
Mortality assumptionsNot every seedling survives — usually not close
Thinning and harvest cyclesManagement removes biomass on a schedule
Project durationHow far the projection runs

Mortality is the input developers most often set optimistically. A projection assuming 95% survival in conditions that deliver 70% is not slightly wrong; it is wrong by a quarter, compounding through every subsequent year.

Density Is Physically Bounded

The library ships a stand-density reference relating average diameter and crown dimensions to a maximum trees per hectare — at 10 cm average DBH with a 2 m crown, roughly 3,180 trees/ha; at 20 cm with a 4 m crown, around 796.

The reason this matters: crowns compete for space. A projection that grows every planted seedling to maturity at planting density is describing a stand that cannot physically exist, because the crowns would have to overlap.

The reference ships as data, so the ceiling is checkable rather than asserted:

text
Average Pop DBH [cm], Crown Diameter [m], Crown Cover [m^2], Max Stand Density [trees/ha]
        10.0,                2.0,               3,                    3183
        20.0,                4.0,              13,                     796

Planting 1,600 stems/ha and projecting all of them to 20 cm DBH claims roughly twice the stand the crowns can physically occupy. The ceiling is what forces the model to resolve that — through mortality, thinning, or a slower trajectory.

Any credible ex-ante model needs a density ceiling that forces either mortality or thinning as the stand matures. Models without one produce impressive numbers that a forester recognises immediately as impossible.

Ex-Ante Is a Hypothesis

The critical framing, and the one that keeps projects out of trouble: an ex-ante estimate is a projection, not an entitlement.

Credits are issued against measured, verified performance. The ex-ante number exists to size the opportunity, structure the financing and design the monitoring — not to be sold.

Projects that treat the projection as a forward commitment end up in difficulty when reality comes in below it, which it frequently does. Mortality in the first two years, drought, grazing, fire and slower-than-modelled early growth all push the same direction.

Why It Belongs Beside the Ex-Post Tooling

The repository holds both `ex_ante` and `ex_post` for a reason. The projection and the measurement should share species parameters, allometric equations and structure, so that comparing them compares like with like.

When measured stock diverges from projection, a shared parameter set tells you whether the divergence came from the growth assumption, the mortality assumption or the measurement. Separate tools with separate parameters cannot answer that, and the divergence becomes an argument rather than a diagnosis.

The Sensitivity Analysis Nobody Runs

Because the tool is scriptable, running the projection across a range of mortality and growth assumptions costs almost nothing.

Doing so produces a range rather than a point, which is a more honest input to a financial model and tends to change how projects are structured. A developer who has seen the low case is more likely to build in the margin that makes the project survive it.

Turn uncertainty into a plan

Sampling design and growth assumptions decide how much measured carbon survives conservative deduction. TREEO Carbon Simulator models sequestration scenarios and biomass growth before the field season.

Related Articles

Ex-Ante Carbon Estimation Tool for ARR Projects | TREEO Indonesia