A project that stops clearing inside its boundary while the same people clear an equivalent area just outside has achieved nothing for the atmosphere and everything for its own accounts. Leakage accounting exists to close that gap, and it is the part of carbon methodology where the honest answer is most often "we can bound this, not measure it."
Two Kinds, Very Different Difficulty
| Type | What happens | Detectability |
|---|---|---|
| Activity shifting | The same agents move their activity to nearby land | Observable — monitor the surrounding belt |
| Market leakage | Reduced supply raises prices, inducing production elsewhere | Not observable — must be modelled |
Activity shifting is tractable. You identify who was doing the clearing, you define a leakage belt around the project, and you monitor it with the same methods used inside. If clearing rises in the belt after the project starts, you deduct it.
Market leakage is genuinely hard. If a project reduces timber supply, the price effect propagates through a market that may be national or international, and the induced production could occur anywhere. No monitoring design catches it.
How Market Leakage Is Handled
Standards generally apply a default discount, which is a fixed percentage deduction based on the activity type and the commodity involved, rather than requiring measurement.
This is an admission that the quantity cannot be observed, packaged as a conservative assumption. It is a reasonable compromise and it should be understood as one. A project reporting market leakage as a precise figure derived from a default percentage is reporting an assumption with false precision.
The discount is typically larger where the displaced product is highly tradable and smaller where it is consumed locally. A project displacing subsistence fuelwood collection faces a smaller market-leakage assumption than one displacing commercial timber, and the reasoning is sound: there is less of a market to leak into.
Designing the Leakage Belt
For activity shifting, the belt definition drives the result.
Too narrow and displaced activity happens beyond it, undetected. Too wide and unrelated regional clearing gets attributed to the project, producing deductions it did not cause.
The defensible basis is the agents' actual mobility: how far do the people identified in the driver analysis realistically travel to clear land? That is an empirical question with a local answer, and it links the leakage design back to the driver analysis rather than to an arbitrary buffer distance.
The Design That Reduces Leakage Rather Than Measuring It
The strongest leakage argument is structural: a project that gives the agents a better alternative in place generates less displacement than one that excludes them.
If clearing was driven by a need for productive land and the project raises productivity on land already in use, there is less reason to clear elsewhere. If the project simply fences the area, the need has not changed and will be met somewhere.
This is not only an ethical point. Projects built on exclusion carry a persistent leakage liability that must be monitored and deducted for their entire life. Projects built on substitution reduce that liability at the source and the deduction they avoid is often larger than the cost of the substitution programme.
Turn climate goals into a verified portfolio
TREEO connects the full carbon cycle, encompassing eligibility, simulation, real time monitoring, and registry ready reporting, thereby combining expert consulting with dMRV technology so the evidence exists before anyone asks for it.



