Documentary photograph illustrating trees and Shrubs
← Back to blog

Trees and Shrubs: Where the Measurement Threshold Decides the Answer

Sustainability•20 October 2026•TREEO Indonesia•2 min read

Every forest inventory begins with a decision that rarely gets discussed: how big does a woody stem have to be before you measure it? The answer is usually a diameter threshold — 5 cm, 10 cm, sometimes 2.5 cm — and in a young ARR project it can change the reported carbon stock by a large fraction.

The Threshold Is Not a Detail

In a mature forest, stems below 10 cm diameter hold a small share of total biomass. Raising or lowering the threshold changes the answer modestly.

In a five-year-old planting, most of the stems are below 10 cm. The same threshold now excludes most of the carbon the project has actually accumulated.

Stand ageShare of biomass in stems <10 cm DBHThreshold sensitivity
Young planting (3–7 yr)LargeHigh — choice dominates result
Establishing (8–15 yr)ModerateModerate
Mature forestSmallLow

This is why ARR projects and REDD+ projects often use different thresholds, and why a threshold borrowed from a natural-forest inventory protocol can badly understate a plantation's early growth.

Shrubs Are a Separate Problem

Shrubs are woody, they hold carbon, and they are poorly served by tree allometry. A multi-stemmed shrub has no single DBH to feed an equation built on single-stemmed trees.

Methodologies handle this in one of three ways: a separate shrub allometric equation using crown dimensions, a default biomass value per unit of shrub cover, or exclusion of the pool entirely on conservativeness grounds.

Exclusion is legitimate and often sensible — if the pool is small and the project is not claiming it, ignoring it is conservative. It stops being sensible if shrubs are a substantial part of what the project actually established.

What Changes Between Baseline and Project

The conservativeness logic reverses depending on which side of the ledger a pool sits on.

Excluding shrubs from the project scenario is conservative — you claim less than you have. Excluding them from the baseline is anti-conservative, because it makes the starting point look emptier than it was, inflating the difference.

Projects that exclude a pool must exclude it consistently, or justify asymmetric treatment explicitly. Assessors check this directly, and an asymmetry that happens to favour the project is one of the faster routes to a finding.

The Practical Recommendation

Set the threshold from the stand you actually have, not the protocol you inherited. Document why. And if the threshold changes between monitoring events, the time series breaks — recalculate the earlier events on the new basis, or the trend you report is an artefact of your own definition.

Turn uncertainty into a plan

Sampling design and growth assumptions decide how much measured carbon survives conservative deduction. TREEO Carbon Simulator models sequestration scenarios and biomass growth before the field season.

Related Articles

Tree and Shrub Biomass Pools in Carbon Projects | TREEO Indonesia