Most avoided-deforestation projects argue about a counterfactual nobody can observe. Avoided planned conversion is different: the forest had documented legal permission to be cleared, and the project pays for it not to be. That makes the baseline unusually evidenced — and the additionality test unusually sharp.
Why the Baseline Is Easier Here
| Unplanned deforestation | Avoided planned conversion | |
|---|---|---|
| Baseline evidence | Statistical — historical rates, risk models | Documentary — permits, plans, approvals |
| Who would clear | Diffuse actors | An identified party with legal rights |
| Timing | Probabilistic | Often scheduled |
| Contested? | Frequently | Less so, where documents are genuine |
A concession holder with an approved conversion plan, a permit and a schedule provides exactly the evidence an unplanned-deforestation baseline lacks. You are not modelling risk; you are pointing at a document.
Why Additionality Is Harder
The same clarity cuts the other way.
If conversion was legally permitted and commercially attractive, the project must show carbon revenue is what changed the decision. If conversion was permitted but not commercially viable — a plan that would never have been executed — then the forest was not really at risk, and the credits are not additional.
Assessors examine this directly: was the conversion plan funded, scheduled and economically sound, or was it a permit held speculatively? The second is common, and it is fatal to the claim.
The Moral Hazard Problem
The obvious concern: a system that pays landowners not to clear forest they had permission to clear creates an incentive to obtain such permission.
Standards address this with eligibility rules about when the permit was obtained relative to the project, and by testing whether conversion was genuinely imminent. Projects working in this space should expect that scrutiny and document the permit history thoroughly — including that it predates any carbon discussion.
Where It Fits in Indonesia
Indonesia has substantial forest under concession arrangements where conversion is legally possible. That makes avoided planned conversion structurally relevant — and makes the permit-history and commercial-viability evidence the centre of any credible project file.
A project that can show a funded, scheduled, economically sound conversion plan that carbon revenue displaced has one of the strongest baselines available in forest carbon. One that cannot has one of the weakest.
Check the land before you commit
Eligibility turns on land history and forest cover at a cut-off date. TREEO Eligibility runs satellite-based forest cover detection on your area of interest — before a single seed goes into the ground.



