Landscape view of woven mats of varying sizes hung in a row along a line over bare dirt ground, with a wooden hut with a metal roof, palm fronds and green foliage behind.
← Back to blog

Who Owns the Benefits? Legal Status and Project Ownership in CCB

Sustainability•6 November 2026•TREEO Indonesia•4 min read

A carbon project can be well designed and still fail an audit because nobody can show who has the legal right to claim its results. In the Climate, Community & Biodiversity (CCB) Standards version 3.1, this sits in criterion G5, Legal Status and Property Rights. This article covers the Legal Status part of G5: laws, approvals, ownership and double counting. The consent and land dispute parts of G5 are a separate topic.

The four Legal Status requirements

Under the Legal Status heading, G5 asks the project to do four things:

- List the laws. Submit a list of all national and local laws and regulations in the host country that are relevant to the project activities. Give assurance that the project complies and, where relevant, show how. - Document the approvals. Show that the project has approval from the appropriate authorities. This includes the formal and traditional authorities that the communities customarily require. - Show undisputed ownership. Demonstrate that the proponent has the "unconditional, undisputed and unencumbered ability" to claim that the project will or did generate its climate, community and biodiversity benefits. - Say what is tradable and avoid double counting. Identify the tradable climate, community and biodiversity benefits and specify how double counting is avoided. The standard singles out offsets sold on the voluntary market and generated in a country that takes part in a compliance mechanism.

What counts as "local" law

The standard defines local laws broadly. They include all norms issued by bodies of government below national level, such as departmental or municipal rules, and customary norms. So a legal register that only lists national statutes is incomplete under this wording.

Why traditional authorities appear

The approvals requirement does not stop at the state. It says the approvals must come from the appropriate state, local and indigenous authorities, and that the documents must show approval from the "established formal and/or traditional authorities customarily required by the communities". For a project design this means mapping, early, who the communities themselves expect to sign off. That map is not always the same as the government organisation chart.

The six routes to project ownership

The word "ownership" is defined in the standard in a footnote. It corresponds to the legal right to control and operate project activities. Ownership may be accorded to the proponent in these circumstances:

RouteIn plain terms
1Ownership arises or is granted under a statute, regulation or decree by a competent authority
2Ownership arises under law
3A statutory, property or contractual right in the plant, equipment or process that generates the reductions, removals or benefits, where that right includes ownership of them and has not been given away
4A statutory, property or contractual right in the land, vegetation or conservation or management process that generates them, again including ownership of the results and not divested
5An enforceable and irrevocable agreement with the holder of the right in the plant, equipment or process, vesting ownership in the proponent
6An enforceable and irrevocable agreement with the holder of the right in the land, vegetation or conservation or management process, vesting ownership in the proponent

Two features are worth noticing:

- Routes 3 to 6 each say the right must include ownership of the resulting reductions, removals and benefits, and that the proponent must not have been divested of it. Owning land is not automatically the same as owning the carbon. - Routes 5 and 6 are for proponents who do not hold the right themselves. They need an agreement that is both enforceable and irrevocable. A revocable licence or an informal understanding does not match this wording.

A note on three kinds of benefit

The ownership test in G5 does not only cover emission reductions or removals. It covers climate, community and biodiversity benefits. When a project uses CCB together with a carbon standard, the carbon units are quantified elsewhere. G5 still asks the proponent to be able to claim all three kinds of benefit without dispute.

Double counting under G5

The double counting duty has two parts:

1. Identify which benefits are tradable. 2. Explain how the project avoids counting them twice.

The standard names the situation of greatest concern: offsets sold on the voluntary market that are generated in a country taking part in a compliance mechanism. It does not prescribe a mechanism in this passage. A project should therefore describe its own arrangements clearly and expect the validation body to test them.

A practical checklist

This list is our reading of the requirements, not text from the standard:

- A legal register with national, sub-national and customary norms, each with a short compliance note. - Copies of approvals from state and local bodies, plus a record of approval from the traditional authorities the communities named. - A short ownership memo that states which of the six routes applies, with the supporting instrument attached. - If a landowner or community is the rights holder, the agreement that vests the results in the proponent, with proof that it is enforceable and irrevocable. - A paragraph on tradable benefits and on double counting arrangements.

Common gaps

- Treating a land lease as proof of carbon ownership when the lease is silent on the results. - Listing national laws but not local or customary norms. - Obtaining a permit from a government office but nothing from the authority the community recognises. - Describing only the carbon units and ignoring community and biodiversity benefits.

Takeaway

Legal status is a document exercise that starts early. If the ownership route is unclear at design stage, it will not become clearer at audit. Choose the route, collect the instrument, and keep the register current as laws and agreements change.

Turn climate goals into a verified portfolio

TREEO connects the full carbon cycle — eligibility, simulation, real-time monitoring and registry-ready reporting — combining expert consulting with dMRV technology so the evidence exists before anyone asks for it.

Related Articles

CCB G5: Legal Status and Project Ownership Explained | TREEO Indonesia