How far back should a baseline look? Ten years produces one deforestation rate; fifteen produces another. Both are defensible in isolation, which is exactly why the selection needs a reason beyond the number it produces.
Why the Window Length Changes the Answer
Land-use change is episodic. A road opens, pressure spikes for several years, then the accessible frontier moves on.
A window that captures the spike produces a high historical rate. One that starts after it produces a low one. Neither is wrong about the data; they are answering different questions about what the recent past represents.
| Window choice | Tends to produce | Risk |
|---|---|---|
| Short, recent | Reflects current conditions | Sensitive to a single event |
| Long | Smooths episodic variation | May include conditions that no longer apply |
| Ending before a known event | Excludes a spike | Reads as selection to favour the project |
What Makes a Selection Defensible
Methodology compliance first. Most methodologies specify a permitted range. Selection happens inside that range, not around it.
A stated rationale. Why this window reflects the conditions expected in the crediting period, such as data availability, a change in policy or access, or the completion of a land use transition.
Sensitivity disclosure. Showing what the rate would have been under the adjacent plausible windows. A project that discloses this and explains the choice is in a far stronger position than one presenting a single number.
The Test Assessors Apply
They ask whether a different, equally reasonable analyst would have selected the same period from the same evidence and whether the project would have made the same choice if it produced a lower baseline.
That second question is uncomfortable and it is the right one. A selection that only works in the project's favour, with no independent justification, is the pattern that drew criticism to forest carbon baselines in the first place.
This is also part of why standards have been moving toward jurisdictional allocation, where the period is set centrally and the project does not choose at all.
Turn climate goals into a verified portfolio
TREEO connects the full carbon cycle, encompassing eligibility, simulation, real time monitoring, and registry ready reporting, thereby combining expert consulting with dMRV technology so the evidence exists before anyone asks for it.



