Forest and wetland carbon can be lost after credits are issued. A fire, a drainage channel or a legal dispute can undo the benefit. Every AFOLU standard handles that with a reserve of credits that are set aside and not sold. This post shows how one BioCarbon PDD reaches a 20 percent reserve, using the weighted risk score in the document. For the general logic of buffer pools, see our post on buffer pool mechanics.
Two reserves, 10 percent each
In the PDD the reserve has two parts:
- Project reserve: 10 percent of verified credits are withheld in a reserve account for the project. - BioCarbon general reserve: a further 10 percent is automatically allocated to the programme's general fund.
Together they make a 20 percent credit buffer. The PDD calls this "environmental insurance". If a verified reversal happens, it is offset one to one from these reserves.
The general reserve is fixed. The project reserve is where the risk score does its work: the PDD says a low risk profile earns a 10 percent contribution, and it states the rule as a score of 1.7 or less giving 10 percent. Higher scores would presumably give higher shares, but the PDD does not show the other bands, so we do not state them here.
The five-category risk score
The PDD scores five risk categories. Each has a weight in percent, a score from 1 to 5 (lower is better), and a written justification.
| Category | Weight | Score | Justification in the PDD |
|---|---|---|---|
| Land tenure and legal | 35 percent | 1 | Documented private tenure, no ongoing legal conflicts |
| Natural and environmental | 15 percent | 3 | Exposure to fires, invasive species and climate variability, with mitigation in place |
| Financial and operational | 15 percent | 2 | Financing secured through carbon credits and conservation funds, trained technical team |
| Governance and political | 10 percent | 1 | Regulatory stability, alignment with national climate law and policy |
| Community participation | 25 percent | 2 | Public consultation done, local participation in monitoring, benefit distribution mechanism still being developed |
The weights add up to 100 percent. The final score is the weighted sum:
(1 × 0.35) + (3 × 0.15) + (2 × 0.15) + (1 × 0.10) + (2 × 0.25) = 0.35 + 0.45 + 0.30 + 0.10 + 0.50 = 1.70
That lands exactly on the 1.7 line, so the project reserve is 10 percent. A single point on any 15 percent category would change the answer: moving natural risk from 3 to 4 would add 0.15 and push the total to 1.85, above the line. This is why each score needs a written reason that a verifier can check.
What a heavy weight tells you
Land tenure carries 35 percent in this PDD, the largest weight, and community participation carries 25 percent. The two together are 60 percent of the score. The practical reading is that tenure and community buy-in drive the reserve more than fire or finance do. The PDD scores community participation 2, not 1, and its justification openly says the benefit distribution mechanism is still under development. Honest scoring of this kind is easier to defend than a perfect score.
Reversal measures
The PDD lists what the project does to prevent reversal. They are tied to the activity, in this case peatland conservation:
- satellite fire monitoring and trained local brigades, - active control of invasive species, - water table sensors to detect unauthorised drainage, - patrols against illegal extraction, - contingency plans for extreme weather events, - upkeep of hydrological integrity and native vegetation.
These measures are the evidence behind the natural and environmental score of 3. Listing them without monitoring would not support a lower score.
Classifying a reversal
The PDD says every reversal must be classed as avoidable or unavoidable.
- Avoidable: caused by negligence or a lack of mitigation measures, for example a fire that follows inadequate monitoring. - Unavoidable: caused by extreme natural events such as lightning or an earthquake, despite reasonable mitigation.
If a reversal happens, the project must submit a Loss Event Report within 12 months, with a conservative estimate of the organic carbon lost. Compensation then runs as follows:
- Avoidable reversals are covered from the project reserve or the general reserve, and may raise the project's future contribution. - Unavoidable reversals can be covered from the same reserve without added penalty, as long as the monitoring and response protocols were followed.
The second rule gives a practical reason to keep monitoring records: they decide whether a loss carries a penalty.
Practical points
- Score each category from evidence, and write the evidence next to the score. - Check the weighted sum, and test how close it is to a band edge. - Keep the risk measures in your monitoring plan so they can be verified. - Plan to file a loss report inside 12 months if something does go wrong.
TREEO can help prepare the risk table and its supporting evidence before a verifier reads it.
Let's build your verified carbon portfolio
A carbon project demands rigorous science, strict compliance and flawless data. TREEO guides projects from feasibility through validation and verification — and builds the evidence that survives each audit.



