Documentary photograph illustrating quantifying IFM Reductions
← Back to blog

Quantifying IFM Reductions: Where the Harvested Wood Goes

Forest•9 October 2026•TREEO Indonesia•2 min read

An ARR project's carbon stays in the forest. An IFM project's carbon partly leaves it, specifically as logs on trucks, and what the accounting says happens next determines a large share of the credited quantity. This is the harvested wood products question, and it is where IFM quantification gets genuinely difficult.

The Basic Structure

The reduction is the difference in total carbon between baseline and project, where "total" includes both the standing forest and the carbon embodied in wood removed from it.

ComponentBaseline scenarioProject scenario
Standing biomassLower (more harvesting)Higher
Carbon in long-lived wood productsHigherLower
Carbon in short-lived products and mill residueHigherLower

Ignore the product pools and an IFM project that reduces harvest appears to gain the full standing-stock difference. Include them and part of that gain is offset by the wood products the baseline would have produced and the project does not.

Why Product Accounting Cuts Against the Project

This is counterintuitive until you see it. A baseline that harvests more also produces more timber, and some of that timber holds carbon for decades in buildings and furniture.

The project reduces harvest, so it also reduces that stored product carbon. Full accounting requires subtracting it, which reduces the net claim.

Methodologies that include harvested wood products therefore yield smaller reductions than those that ignore them and the ones that ignore them are sometimes defended as conservative, which is wrong in this direction. Omitting a pool that is larger in the baseline inflates the difference.

How Product Carbon Is Actually Estimated

Nobody tracks individual logs. The standard approach applies default fractions: a proportion of harvested carbon goes to long-lived products, a proportion to short-lived, and a proportion is lost immediately as mill residue and processing waste.

Those fractions vary by species, product mix and local mill efficiency, and the defaults are coarse. A project with actual mill data and product-mix records can do better and should, because the defaults were not derived from Indonesian processing conditions.

Decay Is Modelled, Not Observed

Even long lived products decay eventually. Methodologies apply decay functions over decades, which is an assumption rather than a measurement, and one that no project will ever verify within its own lifetime.

The practical consequence is that HWP accounting introduces a modelled component into an otherwise measurement-based calculation. Projects should be explicit that this term is modelled, and should report their results with and without it where the methodology allows, so readers can see how much of the answer depends on the assumption.

What to Check Before Choosing a Methodology

Whether the methodology includes harvested wood products, and how. It changes the creditable quantity materially, and it is a structural property of the methodology that cannot be adjusted later.

A developer comparing two IFM methodologies on expected yield without checking this is comparing numbers that were not calculated on the same basis.

Where science meets climate action

TREEO Indonesia pairs expert consulting with dMRV technology across afforestation and reforestation, agroforestry, regenerative agriculture, and biochar, moving from project design through to verified issuance.

Related Articles

Emission Reduction from IFM Activities | TREEO Indonesia