Documentary photograph illustrating improved Forest Management
← Back to blog

Improved Forest Management: Five Activity Types, One Common Failure

Forest•13 October 2026•TREEO Indonesia•2 min read

Improved forest management is the least glamorous category in forest carbon and, in Indonesia, arguably the most relevant, as there is far more forest already under management than there is degraded land awaiting planting. It is also the category where the most projects fail, and nearly always for the same reason.

The Activity Types

ActivityWhat changesCarbon effect
Logged to protectedHarvesting ceasesLarge, front-loaded
Extended rotationLonger harvest cycleModerate, sustained
Reduced-impact loggingLess collateral damage per volume extractedModest per hectare, large in aggregate
Increased stockingEnrichment planting, thinning regimesSlow
Avoided planned conversionLegally permitted clearing does not occurLarge

They differ enormously in scale of effect, cost and evidence burden. What they share is the structure of the claim: the forest exists either way, and the project is arguing that it will hold more carbon than it otherwise would have.

The Common Failure

In ARR the counterfactual is usually visible, such as bare land, and you can photograph it. In IFM the counterfactual is a management decision that was never taken, and the only evidence for it is documentary.

This is where projects fail. The baseline rests on what the operator would have harvested, and that requires: an approved management plan, historical harvest records, financial models showing the harvest was viable, and a demonstration that the operator had both the right and the intention to proceed.

Projects that assert a baseline harvest level without records to support it are asserting the entire claim. A forest that was not going to be logged anyway generates no credits by not being logged, and assessors start from that presumption rather than the reverse.

Reduced-Impact Logging Deserves More Attention

RIL is often overlooked because the per-hectare effect is modest. That undersells it in the Indonesian context.

Conventional selective logging damages a large amount of residual stand per tree extracted, through felling direction, skid trail construction, and canopy tearing. Planned felling, pre marked skid trails, and directional felling reduce that collateral damage substantially while extracting comparable volume.

The effect per hectare is small; the area under production forest management is very large. And critically, RIL does not require the operator to give up revenue, which removes the additionality complication that harvest-deferral activities carry. The baseline argument is about technique, not about forgone income.

Where the Measurement Difficulty Sits

IFM asks you to detect a difference between two substantial forests. The signal is a modest percentage of a large stock, measured over years, which is precisely the regime where measurement design determines whether the effect is detectable at all.

Permanent plots become close to mandatory. Differencing independent samples from a heterogeneous forest produces confidence intervals wide enough to swallow the entire claimed effect, so a project can genuinely achieve a 10% stock increase and be unable to demonstrate it.

Who IFM Suits

Operators with existing concessions, documented management history, and a real harvest they can evidence. That combination is more common in Indonesia than the current project mix suggests, and the constraint is usually records rather than forest.

Concession holders considering this should start by auditing their own documentation. If the harvest history is not reconstructable, the baseline is not defensible, and no amount of field measurement later will fix it.

Where science meets climate action

TREEO Indonesia pairs expert consulting with dMRV technology across afforestation and reforestation, agroforestry, regenerative agriculture, and biochar, moving from project design through to verified issuance.

Related Articles

Improved Forest Management (IFM) Carbon Projects | TREEO Indonesia